Israel, Jews, Antisemitism 24/7 - Who is the Problem Here
A debate erupted on X this week after the Daily Wire’s Matt Walsh, pushed the idea that the Right must unite in order to win.
Walsh posted: “The Right doesn’t stick together; that’s our biggest problem by far. Conservatives are quick to denounce each other, jump on dogpiles, disavow, attack their allies .... The Left will keep up the united front and defend their guys no matter what while we keep throwing each other to the wolves at every opportunity. Great plan.”
Walsh followed up by adding “We need to stop the in-fighting and unite against the threat of the Left”.
One American Jew 'right-winger' concluded his opinion believing that Walsh statement was directed to those who are supporting Israel and those who aren't by this statement: "The last time I checked, we were already winning without embracing the worst among our ranks. We have President Donald Trump — the most pro-Israel and pro-Jewish president in history, to the chagrin of many — in the White House. His Republican Party controls the House and the Senate, we have a conservative majority in the Supreme Court, and countless state legislative, executive, and judicial bodies are similarly conservative!
Call me crazy, but I’ll choose this sort of winning while also working to keep the worst fringes of our own side from becoming mainstream, lest I have no political home left. That means calling out the Left, yes, but it also means gatekeeping what we’re even fighting for in the first place. If we don’t do that, what it is to “win” becomes meaningless."
— It sounds that he's in fear for Israel losing support of right-wing voters more than the issues Americans are facing. He forgets that American voters are voting for the US government, not for Israel's. I completely understand his concerns, - the concern that comes from Jewish perspective of adaptation of being American Jew - that American Jew are just a Jews abroad, no matter where they are born or reside. That narrative was set long time ago and broadly promoted by Russian-born Zionist leader who become the first president of Jewish state of Israel, Chaim Weizmann, who once said "There are no English, French, German or American Jews, but only Jews living in England, France, Germany or America.
So, basically Jews abroad are instructed to accept this definition of citizenship, - that they are among us, but they never will be us.
That being said I like to add something to fulfill this context by the fact that Israel, a Middle East state is allowed to participate in Eurovision Song Competition and European sport leagues. Despite the fact the many European Jews are part of music and sports scene, their interest in representing the state of citizenship is not important to them as representing the state of Israel.
And the fact that American Jews were huge part of the left-wing policies and flooding our streets with immigrants by promoting a "Melting Pot", now when they notice that Israel is losing support of left-wing voters who don't wish to stay silent to their enforced complicity in genocide in Palestine, they switched their political belief to the right-wing and fighting so-called antisemitism with islamophobia demanding from AIPAC money receivers to rid of those who are against Israel, to implement their narrative in our school system, and basically place themselves over others in US in the level of importance.
They are using two-headed snake party system to divide Americans and to thrive of the divide. If we keep letting them to divide us and keep redirecting our money to Israel where its citizens enjoy free education and free healthcare, while we must pay for everything - our future is not very promising. We need to understand that their Israel First agenda is the main reason for heigh gasoline prices, because Israel is the one that is interrupting the production and distribution of Oil with their endless wars of hate against their neighbors and keeping Middle East destabilized. All of this influencing gasoline prices. And with that all other prices. From food to housing cost, it's all in connection with Oil.
Also, with all that being said let me remind you of what Richard Nixon once said about American Jews in a July 3, 1971, conversation with H.R. Haldeman, per White House tape transcripts: "The government is full of Jews... most Jews are disloyal... you can’t trust the bastards. They turn on you."
And let face it, there will be never peace in the Middle East until Israel is dismantled. Some may think that is unrealistic, but many are believing that Brits made huge mistake for establishing Israel in the first place.
In contrast, imagine yourself and your own body, some doctor comes to idea to implant the third hand in the middle of your back. After recovery you are not able to sleep on your back, to rest, to sunbath, to sit in the seat to drive a car. And on top of that, the third hand is frequently flicking back of your ears. So, what do you do?
I bet you would tell doctor to remove that third hand because you have witnessed that third hand is only giving you trouble and no benefit at all.
That it's same with Israel. State of Israel is not organic; it is placed there by the powerful Brits who were owned by the rich Jewish bankers. It is a failed project and for that reason must be dismantled.
And when we're talking about Brits, there is a news that the UK Councils rejected to adopt IHRA anti-Semitism definition in defiance of government plea.
More than 100 councils have rejected consistent Government calls to adopt an international definition of anti-Semitism, Telegraph analysis reveals.
Nearly a third of all local authorities in the UK have not outlined a commitment to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) definition of anti-Semitism and its 11 listed examples.
— I believe that is a great decision. No government should let the bulletproof IHRA definition to be adopted. Nobody is against Semitic people, because if we are pro-Palestine we are pro-Semitic also. Arabs are Semitic people as well. Something that we can't say with all certainty for large number of modern-day Israelis who aren't Semitic but European descent.
There's no archaeological or genetic record that European Jews came from the Middle East. To label someone as antisemitic when they are talking against Israel it's same as labeling someone who dislikes soft drinks as anti-alcoholic. By IHRA bulletproof definition of antisemitism, even disliking the taste of chocolate babka is antisemitism.
To end this with a quote of former Israeli government member, Shulamit Aloni: "Antisemitism is a trick that we always use it. When is someone from Europe criticizing Israel, we bring up the Holocaust. When people in US are criticizing Israel then they are anti-Semitic."
A debate erupted on X this week after the Daily Wire’s Matt Walsh, pushed the idea that the Right must unite in order to win.
Walsh posted: “The Right doesn’t stick together; that’s our biggest problem by far. Conservatives are quick to denounce each other, jump on dogpiles, disavow, attack their allies .... The Left will keep up the united front and defend their guys no matter what while we keep throwing each other to the wolves at every opportunity. Great plan.”
Walsh followed up by adding “We need to stop the in-fighting and unite against the threat of the Left”.
One American Jew 'right-winger' concluded his opinion believing that Walsh statement was directed to those who are supporting Israel and those who aren't by this statement: "The last time I checked, we were already winning without embracing the worst among our ranks. We have President Donald Trump — the most pro-Israel and pro-Jewish president in history, to the chagrin of many — in the White House. His Republican Party controls the House and the Senate, we have a conservative majority in the Supreme Court, and countless state legislative, executive, and judicial bodies are similarly conservative!
Call me crazy, but I’ll choose this sort of winning while also working to keep the worst fringes of our own side from becoming mainstream, lest I have no political home left. That means calling out the Left, yes, but it also means gatekeeping what we’re even fighting for in the first place. If we don’t do that, what it is to “win” becomes meaningless."
— It sounds that he's in fear for Israel losing support of right-wing voters more than the issues Americans are facing. He forgets that American voters are voting for the US government, not for Israel's. I completely understand his concerns, - the concern that comes from Jewish perspective of adaptation of being American Jew - that American Jew are just a Jews abroad, no matter where they are born or reside. That narrative was set long time ago and broadly promoted by Russian-born Zionist leader who become the first president of Jewish state of Israel, Chaim Weizmann, who once said "There are no English, French, German or American Jews, but only Jews living in England, France, Germany or America.
So, basically Jews abroad are instructed to accept this definition of citizenship, - that they are among us, but they never will be us.
That being said I like to add something to fulfill this context by the fact that Israel, a Middle East state is allowed to participate in Eurovision Song Competition and European sport leagues. Despite the fact the many European Jews are part of music and sports scene, their interest in representing the state of citizenship is not important to them as representing the state of Israel.
And the fact that American Jews were huge part of the left-wing policies and flooding our streets with immigrants by promoting a "Melting Pot", now when they notice that Israel is losing support of left-wing voters who don't wish to stay silent to their enforced complicity in genocide in Palestine, they switched their political belief to the right-wing and fighting so-called antisemitism with islamophobia demanding from AIPAC money receivers to rid of those who are against Israel, to implement their narrative in our school system, and basically place themselves over others in US in the level of importance.
They are using two-headed snake party system to divide Americans and to thrive of the divide. If we keep letting them to divide us and keep redirecting our money to Israel where its citizens enjoy free education and free healthcare, while we must pay for everything - our future is not very promising. We need to understand that their Israel First agenda is the main reason for heigh gasoline prices, because Israel is the one that is interrupting the production and distribution of Oil with their endless wars of hate against their neighbors and keeping Middle East destabilized. All of this influencing gasoline prices. And with that all other prices. From food to housing cost, it's all in connection with Oil.
Also, with all that being said let me remind you of what Richard Nixon once said about American Jews in a July 3, 1971, conversation with H.R. Haldeman, per White House tape transcripts: "The government is full of Jews... most Jews are disloyal... you can’t trust the bastards. They turn on you."
And let face it, there will be never peace in the Middle East until Israel is dismantled. Some may think that is unrealistic, but many are believing that Brits made huge mistake for establishing Israel in the first place.
In contrast, imagine yourself and your own body, some doctor comes to idea to implant the third hand in the middle of your back. After recovery you are not able to sleep on your back, to rest, to sunbath, to sit in the seat to drive a car. And on top of that, the third hand is frequently flicking back of your ears. So, what do you do?
I bet you would tell doctor to remove that third hand because you have witnessed that third hand is only giving you trouble and no benefit at all.
That it's same with Israel. State of Israel is not organic; it is placed there by the powerful Brits who were owned by the rich Jewish bankers. It is a failed project and for that reason must be dismantled.
And when we're talking about Brits, there is a news that the UK Councils rejected to adopt IHRA anti-Semitism definition in defiance of government plea.
More than 100 councils have rejected consistent Government calls to adopt an international definition of anti-Semitism, Telegraph analysis reveals.
Nearly a third of all local authorities in the UK have not outlined a commitment to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) definition of anti-Semitism and its 11 listed examples.
— I believe that is a great decision. No government should let the bulletproof IHRA definition to be adopted. Nobody is against Semitic people, because if we are pro-Palestine we are pro-Semitic also. Arabs are Semitic people as well. Something that we can't say with all certainty for large number of modern-day Israelis who aren't Semitic but European descent.
There's no archaeological or genetic record that European Jews came from the Middle East. To label someone as antisemitic when they are talking against Israel it's same as labeling someone who dislikes soft drinks as anti-alcoholic. By IHRA bulletproof definition of antisemitism, even disliking the taste of chocolate babka is antisemitism.
To end this with a quote of former Israeli government member, Shulamit Aloni: "Antisemitism is a trick that we always use it. When is someone from Europe criticizing Israel, we bring up the Holocaust. When people in US are criticizing Israel then they are anti-Semitic."